Merge pull request #14413 from prometheus/beorn7/promql

promql: more Kahan summation (avg) and less incremental mean calculation (avg, avg_over_time)

promql/bench_test.go

@@ -165,6 +165,9 @@ func rangeQueryCases() []benchCase {
 		{
 			expr: "sum(a_X)",
 		},
+		{
+			expr: "avg(a_X)",
+		},
 		{
 			expr: "sum without (l)(h_X)",
 		},

promql/engine.go

@@ -2773,15 +2773,19 @@ func vectorElemBinop(op parser.ItemType, lhs, rhs float64, hlhs, hrhs *histogram
 }
 
 type groupedAggregation struct {
+	floatValue     float64
+	histogramValue *histogram.FloatHistogram
+	floatMean      float64
+	floatKahanC    float64 // "Compensating value" for Kahan summation.
+	groupCount     float64
+	heap           vectorByValueHeap
+
+	// All bools together for better packing within the struct.
 	seen              bool // Was this output groups seen in the input at this timestamp.
 	hasFloat          bool // Has at least 1 float64 sample aggregated.
 	hasHistogram      bool // Has at least 1 histogram sample aggregated.
-	floatValue        float64
+	groupAggrComplete bool // Used by LIMITK to short-cut series loop when we've reached K elem on every group.
-	histogramValue    *histogram.FloatHistogram
+	incrementalMean   bool // True after reverting to incremental calculation of the mean value.
-	floatMean         float64 // Mean, or "compensating value" for Kahan summation.
-	groupCount        int
-	groupAggrComplete bool // Used by LIMITK to short-cut series loop when we've reached K elem on every group
-	heap              vectorByValueHeap
 }
 
 // aggregation evaluates sum, avg, count, stdvar, stddev or quantile at one timestep on inputMatrix.
@@ -2807,13 +2811,11 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 			*group = groupedAggregation{
 				seen:       true,
 				floatValue: f,
+				floatMean:  f,
 				groupCount: 1,
 			}
 			switch op {
-			case parser.AVG:
+			case parser.AVG, parser.SUM:
-				group.floatMean = f
-				fallthrough
-			case parser.SUM:
 				if h == nil {
 					group.hasFloat = true
 				} else {
@@ -2821,7 +2823,6 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 					group.hasHistogram = true
 				}
 			case parser.STDVAR, parser.STDDEV:
-				group.floatMean = f
 				group.floatValue = 0
 			case parser.QUANTILE:
 				group.heap = make(vectorByValueHeap, 1)
@@ -2847,7 +2848,7 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 				// point in copying the histogram in that case.
 			} else {
 				group.hasFloat = true
-				group.floatValue, group.floatMean = kahanSumInc(f, group.floatValue, group.floatMean)
+				group.floatValue, group.floatKahanC = kahanSumInc(f, group.floatValue, group.floatKahanC)
 			}
 
 		case parser.AVG:
@@ -2855,8 +2856,8 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 			if h != nil {
 				group.hasHistogram = true
 				if group.histogramValue != nil {
-					left := h.Copy().Div(float64(group.groupCount))
+					left := h.Copy().Div(group.groupCount)
-					right := group.histogramValue.Copy().Div(float64(group.groupCount))
+					right := group.histogramValue.Copy().Div(group.groupCount)
 					toAdd, err := left.Sub(right)
 					if err != nil {
 						handleAggregationError(err, e, inputMatrix[si].Metric.Get(model.MetricNameLabel), &annos)
@@ -2871,6 +2872,22 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 				// point in copying the histogram in that case.
 			} else {
 				group.hasFloat = true
+				if !group.incrementalMean {
+					newV, newC := kahanSumInc(f, group.floatValue, group.floatKahanC)
+					if !math.IsInf(newV, 0) {
+						// The sum doesn't overflow, so we propagate it to the
+						// group struct and continue with the regular
+						// calculation of the mean value.
+						group.floatValue, group.floatKahanC = newV, newC
+						break
+					}
+					// If we are here, we know that the sum _would_ overflow. So
+					// instead of continue to sum up, we revert to incremental
+					// calculation of the mean value from here on.
+					group.incrementalMean = true
+					group.floatMean = group.floatValue / (group.groupCount - 1)
+					group.floatKahanC /= group.groupCount - 1
+				}
 				if math.IsInf(group.floatMean, 0) {
 					if math.IsInf(f, 0) && (group.floatMean > 0) == (f > 0) {
 						// The `floatMean` and `s.F` values are `Inf` of the same sign.  They
@@ -2888,8 +2905,13 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 						break
 					}
 				}
+				currentMean := group.floatMean + group.floatKahanC
+				group.floatMean, group.floatKahanC = kahanSumInc(
 					// Divide each side of the `-` by `group.groupCount` to avoid float64 overflows.
-				group.floatMean += f/float64(group.groupCount) - group.floatMean/float64(group.groupCount)
+					f/group.groupCount-currentMean/group.groupCount,
+					group.floatMean,
+					group.floatKahanC,
+				)
 			}
 
 		case parser.GROUP:
@@ -2912,7 +2934,7 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 			if h == nil { // Ignore native histograms.
 				group.groupCount++
 				delta := f - group.floatMean
-				group.floatMean += delta / float64(group.groupCount)
+				group.floatMean += delta / group.groupCount
 				group.floatValue += delta * (f - group.floatMean)
 			}
 
@@ -2938,20 +2960,23 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 				annos.Add(annotations.NewMixedFloatsHistogramsAggWarning(e.Expr.PositionRange()))
 				continue
 			}
-			if aggr.hasHistogram {
+			switch {
+			case aggr.hasHistogram:
 				aggr.histogramValue = aggr.histogramValue.Compact(0)
-			} else {
+			case aggr.incrementalMean:
-				aggr.floatValue = aggr.floatMean
+				aggr.floatValue = aggr.floatMean + aggr.floatKahanC
+			default:
+				aggr.floatValue = (aggr.floatValue + aggr.floatKahanC) / aggr.groupCount
 			}
 
 		case parser.COUNT:
-			aggr.floatValue = float64(aggr.groupCount)
+			aggr.floatValue = aggr.groupCount
 
 		case parser.STDVAR:
-			aggr.floatValue /= float64(aggr.groupCount)
+			aggr.floatValue /= aggr.groupCount
 
 		case parser.STDDEV:
-			aggr.floatValue = math.Sqrt(aggr.floatValue / float64(aggr.groupCount))
+			aggr.floatValue = math.Sqrt(aggr.floatValue / aggr.groupCount)
 
 		case parser.QUANTILE:
 			aggr.floatValue = quantile(q, aggr.heap)
@@ -2965,7 +2990,7 @@ func (ev *evaluator) aggregation(e *parser.AggregateExpr, q float64, inputMatrix
 			if aggr.hasHistogram {
 				aggr.histogramValue.Compact(0)
 			} else {
-				aggr.floatValue += aggr.floatMean // Add Kahan summation compensating term.
+				aggr.floatValue += aggr.floatKahanC
 			}
 		default:
 			// For other aggregations, we already have the right value.

promql/functions.go

@@ -580,9 +580,28 @@ func funcAvgOverTime(vals []parser.Value, args parser.Expressions, enh *EvalNode
 		return vec, nil
 	}
 	return aggrOverTime(vals, enh, func(s Series) float64 {
-		var mean, count, c float64
+		var (
+			sum, mean, count, kahanC float64
+			incrementalMean          bool
+		)
 		for _, f := range s.Floats {
 			count++
+			if !incrementalMean {
+				newSum, newC := kahanSumInc(f.F, sum, kahanC)
+				// Perform regular mean calculation as long as
+				// the sum doesn't overflow and (in any case)
+				// for the first iteration (even if we start
+				// with ±Inf) to not run into division-by-zero
+				// problems below.
+				if count == 1 || !math.IsInf(newSum, 0) {
+					sum, kahanC = newSum, newC
+					continue
+				}
+				// Handle overflow by reverting to incremental calculation of the mean value.
+				incrementalMean = true
+				mean = sum / (count - 1)
+				kahanC /= count - 1
+			}
 			if math.IsInf(mean, 0) {
 				if math.IsInf(f.F, 0) && (mean > 0) == (f.F > 0) {
 					// The `mean` and `f.F` values are `Inf` of the same sign.  They
@@ -600,13 +619,13 @@ func funcAvgOverTime(vals []parser.Value, args parser.Expressions, enh *EvalNode
 					continue
 				}
 			}
-			mean, c = kahanSumInc(f.F/count-mean/count, mean, c)
+			correctedMean := mean + kahanC
+			mean, kahanC = kahanSumInc(f.F/count-correctedMean/count, mean, kahanC)
 		}
-
+		if incrementalMean {
-		if math.IsInf(mean, 0) {
+			return mean + kahanC
-			return mean
 		}
-		return mean + c
+		return (sum + kahanC) / count
 	}), nil
 }
 

promql/promqltest/testdata/aggregators.test

@@ -503,7 +503,7 @@ eval instant at 1m avg(data{test="-big"})
 eval instant at 1m avg(data{test="bigzero"})
 	{} 0
 
-# Test summing extreme values.
+# Test summing and averaging extreme values.
 clear
 
 load 10s
@@ -529,21 +529,39 @@ load 10s
 eval instant at 1m sum(data{test="ten"})
 	{} 10
 
+eval instant at 1m avg(data{test="ten"})
+	{} 2.5
+
 eval instant at 1m sum by (group) (data{test="pos_inf"})
 	{group="1"} Inf
 	{group="2"} Inf
 
+eval instant at 1m avg by (group) (data{test="pos_inf"})
+	{group="1"} Inf
+	{group="2"} Inf
+
 eval instant at 1m sum by (group) (data{test="neg_inf"})
 	{group="1"} -Inf
 	{group="2"} -Inf
 
+eval instant at 1m avg by (group) (data{test="neg_inf"})
+	{group="1"} -Inf
+	{group="2"} -Inf
+
 eval instant at 1m sum(data{test="inf_inf"})
 	{} NaN
 
+eval instant at 1m avg(data{test="inf_inf"})
+	{} NaN
+
 eval instant at 1m sum by (group) (data{test="nan"})
 	{group="1"} NaN
 	{group="2"} NaN
 
+eval instant at 1m avg by (group) (data{test="nan"})
+	{group="1"} NaN
+	{group="2"} NaN
+
 clear
 
 # Test that aggregations are deterministic.

promql/promqltest/testdata/functions.test

@@ -748,7 +748,6 @@ eval instant at 1m avg_over_time(metric6c[1m])
 eval instant at 1m sum_over_time(metric6c[1m])/count_over_time(metric6c[1m])
   {} NaN
 
-
 eval instant at 1m avg_over_time(metric7[1m])
   {} NaN
 
@@ -783,6 +782,9 @@ load 10s
 eval instant at 1m sum_over_time(metric[1m])
   {} 2
 
+eval instant at 1m avg_over_time(metric[1m])
+  {} 0.5
+
 # Tests for stddev_over_time and stdvar_over_time.
 clear
 load 10s